Librium Arcana Comic review thread

F&C: Dwarves, Superhero's and Catgirls, oh my!

Moderator: frigidmagi

Post Reply
User avatar
Stofsk
Secret Agent Man
Posts: 1710
Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 4:46 pm
19
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Contact:

#1 Librium Arcana Comic review thread

Post by Stofsk »

P. Craig Russel's "The Ring of the Nibelung" - a comic book adaptation of Richard Wagner's Opera of the same title. Published by Dark Horse.

Image
Image

I started reading this last night in bed, and though I didn't finish it all I can tell you right now, it is beautiful. The artwork is amazing, and really shows what can be done with a graphic print medium like comic books. And the writing translates the Opera into a enjoyable and entertaining read, which is more than what you can ask for. Honestly, this makes me believe in comic books again. Unlike Superman: Red Son, which more or less put me off DC stories for good, there is just a sense of wonder in The Ring and its tale of corruption, betrayal, curses and twilight.

It's good fantasy. Votan/Odin is imperfect, but is tied to the ill-advised bargain he made with the two giants who promised to build him Valhalla. The Rhinegold is a wondrous treasure, but only one who has forsaken love can wield it. Enter Alberich, who does so after being teased mercilessly by three beautiful but cruel mermaid sisters (the guardians of the Rhinegold). He forsakes love, captures the Rhinegold, and makes off to become Lord of the Nibelungs, an underworld of dwarves whom he enslaves to make them toil day and night for his own pleasure. They craft piles of gold trinkets for him, but it is never enough to satisfy him. Votan is of course desperate to find a way to cheat the bargain he made with the giants, who were promised the beautiful goddess Freia who gives the gods their vitality. He cannot let them take away Freia, for it would mean the end of the gods. He cannot renege on the bargain, for the Giants would be outraged and attack him.

So, through the advice of Loge/Loki, the demi-god trickster, he finds a compromise. Seize the rhinegold that has now been fashioned into a ring and worn by Alberich, and use that to tempt the Giants away from Freia. But to do so requires trickery and thievery, and Alberich curses the ring so that any who wield it shall never find contentment, shall only find destruction. Votan/Odin reluctantly gives up the ring to the two Giants, who quickly turn on each other. Once brothers, now enemies. Fafnir emerges triumphant after bludgeoning his brother to death, and claims the ring - and the gods, who had stood aside and watched the butchery, realise what a terrible curse the ring has on it.

And that's all I managed to read. Great stuff, huh? :D I love the fact that there is NO perfect man or character in this. Votan is tied to the bargain he made and cannot free himself from it. Alberich forswears love to have power, and finds neither in the end. Loki is despised by his siblings for not being a 'full' god, and he is bitter and cunning for it. Fafnir kills his own brother because the ring entices him, confirming the curse. And the three sisters who though were playful, were nevertheless cruel to Alberich.

Get it. Read it.
Last edited by Stofsk on Wed Aug 10, 2005 9:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#2

Post by frigidmagi »

I've decided to go ahead and sticky this thread, any other comic reviews should be written in this thread has well. Thank you.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
Cynical Cat
Arch-Magician
Posts: 11930
Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2005 8:53 pm
19
Location: Ice Sarcophagus outside a ruined Jedi Temple
Contact:

#3

Post by Cynical Cat »

The first three volumes (in trade paperback form) of Marvel's The Ultimates.


Everything about these books is excellent. The art is gorgeous, the story writing and characterization is superb, and the look feels epic. There is gore and nudity when it is appropriate, which is not often, and the story has much more of 'real' feel than most comic book stories. The costumes look more like high tech combat gear than superhero wear. There is super tech and super powers, but the feel is closer to that of the Aberrant game or the Authority than of your typical superhero book.

Book 1:
It starts with the opening part in 1945, with Captain America wearing a much more military looking costume and packing a tommy gun as well as a shield, and an assault on a Nazi rocket base sending a futuristic tech nuclear missle at Washington. Captain America is able to get on and deflect it, but ends up in artic waters. Flash forward to the present and General Fury is recruiting the brilliant Doctor Banner for his superhero project. S.H.I.E.L.D. has sucked up a sizable chunk of the military budget and has a mandate of dealing with the new threat. Fury is forming a super powered strike team, the Ultimates. He wants Banner to try and recreate the Captain America super soldier formula.

Various characters are introduced throughout the book. Henry and Jan Pym (Giant Man and Wasp), scientists studying size alteration are brought in. Captain America is recovered and Jan Pym helps him adjust to his new life. Tony Stark, billionaire philanthropist and technologist, brings his assets to the team. Attempts are made to recruit Thor, who may be delusional, but is awesomely powerful. The book climaxes with their first battle against a heavy hitter and the carnage that a supervillian rampage leaves behind.

Book 2:

More fall out from book one. Lives are changed by the climatic events. An ugly side of one of the heroes is revealed and it has repurcussions. An augmented ex-KGB agent (Black Widow) and a black ops killer and master archer (Hawk Eye) lead a strike team against an alien nest. The aliens in question are known to Captain America and pose a very real threat. Events move towards a climax.

Book 3:
Thor recieves a warning that Loki is loose and is going to turn the world against him. Or maybe he's just insane. The Scarlett Witch and Quicksilver, who are involved with S.H.I.E.L.D. in exchange for "considerations", make a larger appearance. The black ops operatives are taking a larger role in things and Widow gets fancy personel armour, courtesy of Tony Stark. Some characters suffer the full consequences of previous actions. The issue with Thor and the future of the Ultimates looms over everyone's head.
It's not that I'm unforgiving, it's that most of the people who wrong me are unrepentant assholes.
Post Reply